Allegation that Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad became Mary

One objection being raised is that Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad may peace be upon him was confused, mad and made silly declarations, therefore they ridicule him for what he said.  For instance, they quote this passage, taking it literally, to show that he was crazy, a false prophet who made ridiculous statements:-

Argument:

God named me Mary in the third volume of Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya (the book of ‘revelations’ written by Mirza).  I was nurtured for two years as Mary and was raised in a womanly seclusion.  Then, the spirit of Jesus was breath into me just as was done with Mary.  Hence, I was considered to be pregnant in a metaphorical manner.  After a period of several months, not exceeding ten, I was made Jesus out of Mary by the revelation embodied in the last part of the fourth volume of Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya; and thus, I became Jesus, son of Mary.  But, God did not inform me of this secret at that time.
Kashti-i-Nuh, Roohani Khazain, Vol. 19, P. 50

Rebuttal:

The actual translation of the passage from our books is as follows:- 

became-Mary

In the third part of Braheen e Ahmadiyya, God had named me Mary and as apparent from it, I was nurtured in the qualities of Mary for two years.  When a period of two years lapsed then, as stated on page 496 of the 4th volume of Braheen e Ahmadiyya, the soul of Jesus was infused in me as it was infused in Mary and, in an allegoric sense, I was stated to be pregnant.  Thereafter, after many months not exceeding a period of ten months after this revelation, I was, through a revelation recorded at the end of Braheen e Ahmadiyya on page 556, named Jesus and hence I came to be the son of Mary.
Kashti Nuh pg 46-47; Roohani Khazain vol 19, pg 50.

Firstly, Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad may peace be upon him is explaining in this quotation why he refers himself to be Jesus, son of Mary, who was prophesised to come in the latter days by the Holy Prophet may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him and by Jesus may peace be upon him himself.  It was the early belief of Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad may peace be upon him, like all Muslims, that Jesus was physically alive in heaven and would return bodily from heaven in the latter days, but when Allah kept referring to Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him as ‘Jesus’, then Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him started to question this belief.  On researching the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith, it became clear to Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him that Jesus was in fact dead!  Then upon researching the Holy Bible he was surprised to discover that the Holy Bible also proved that Jesus was dead.  Thus he started to understand why he was being called ‘Jesus’ by Allah, that the reality was that Jesus was dead and would not return, therefore Allah was making it known to him that he was the spiritual second coming of Jesus.

Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him reached this conclusion after intense study which took a long time.  Therefore in this passage Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him is explaining how he was the spiritual second coming of Jesus and the passage of time it took to come to this understanding.

It is clear from the passage that this was in an allegoric or metaphoric sense, however you want to translate it.  Therefore the first thing we must understand is that he was not saying this was a reality, that ‘he really became Mary’ or that ‘the soul of Jesus really was infused into him’ or that ‘he really became pregnant’, these are just allegories or metaphors being used, to help us understand.

It begins with relating that in the third part of Braheen e Ahmadiyya (there were five parts written from 1880 to the final part in 1905, volume three was written in 1882) God named him Mary.  Now here, just as he was referred to by Allah as ‘Jesus’, so being named ‘Mary’, refers to the spiritual qualities of Mary, who is regarded in the Holy Qur’an as being very pious, submissive, honoured, truthful and one who was granted nearness to Allah.  In fact there is a chapter of the Holy Qur’an Chapter 19 entitled ‘Maryam’.  Therefore she was very honoured by Allah and chosen above others of her time.  By referring Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him to the spiritual qualities of Mary, indicates the high status that Allah bestowed on Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him at that time, that he too had these qualities of being very pious, submissive, honoured, truthful and one that was granted nearness to Allah.

The passage goes on to relate how he, Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him was nurtured by Allah for two years in these qualities.  It shows the high honour that Allah was bestowing on Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him as He had bestowed on Hazrat Maryam may Allah be pleased with him.

Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him then explains that after two years, he wrote Braheen e Ahmadiyya vol 4 in 1884, that Allah was now referring to him as Jesus, just as he had been referred to by Allah as Mary before.  All that he is referring to here is a spiritual rebirth, which he has described like a pregnancy, using an allegory.  Now it is a common way to liken one person to another through their similar qualities.  Just as the Holy Prophet may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him was liken by Hazrat Musa may peace be upon him as ‘a prophet like unto me’, that as Hazrat Musa may peace be upon him was a law-giving prophet who brought the Torah, so a prophet would come with similar qualities as him, i.e. another law-giving prophet – the Holy Prophet Muhammad may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him who brought the Holy Qur’an.  Likewise John the Baptist had the same spiritual qualities as Hazrat Elijah, to whom the Holy Bible relates that he was meant to have gone up into heaven on a chariot of fire and return to proclaim the coming of the Messiah.  This was fulfilled by John the Baptist, when Jesus came to him to be baptised and the dove appeared, meaning that John the Baptist had proclaimed the coming of the Messiah and not a prophet returning from heaven.

So what are the spiritual qualities of Jesus that was infused in Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him?  The qualities of love and forgiveness.  That Jesus had come to instil in the Jews these qualities, as the Jews had become so hard-hearted and took everything literally.  Therefore Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him was commissioned by Allah to bring these spiritual qualities of love and forgiveness to the Muslims, who too had become hard-hearted and took everything literally.

This understanding, that Hazrat Ahmad may peace be upon him was the spiritual coming of Isa ibn Maryam and not that Jesus son of Mary was going to return physically from heaven, took a long time to understand and a lot of research, but he then publically announced that Jesus was dead and will not be returning from heaven, instead he had come as a spiritual return of Jesus, son of Mary.   

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Print this page

  Next Topic